According to the first detailed
examination of sexuality among older Americans many people maintain rich,
active sex lives well into their 80s (Stein). Surprising right? Shouldn’t be.
It shouldn’t be because they are humans too, and if they are still sexually
active good for them! With age, sexual problems such as erectile dysfunction
increase, and the rate of sexual activity decreases. Even as people age, the
interest for intimacy is still there.
Now, what about sexual activity in
the nursing homes? Many nursing homes will split patients up, and segregate
them so that sexual activity is not possible. Most won’t even allow them to
sleep over night. There comes an issue with consent between patients who have
dementia. There was a case in Iowa, where a man and a woman whom both have some
degree of dementia, who were not married (the man was divorced, and the woman
was married to someone on the outside) were discovered in bed; not only once
but twice. One family sued, calling it rape (Here & Now). Because of this,
the man was removed from the home, and the administrator and nursing director
were fired (PBS). The issue here was whether either one of them consented to
the act or not. But, who do you ask and how do you prove it?
However, there is a nursing home that
is encouraging residents to have sex. The nursing home is located in New York
and is known as the Hebrew Home. They not only encourage sex and intimacy but
they support it even among those with dementia. The president and CEO of the
Hebrew Home Daniel Reingold said, ‘they do not give up a civil right simply
because they are in need of nursing care in a facility.’ He also mentions that
just because someone has dementia does not mean that they are incapable of
making a choice in a given moment (Here & Now). It’s great that this
nursing home can implement a policy to allow its residence to continue to have
the intimacy that they long for. But, do elderly patients with dementia have
the capacity to consent to sex?
An interview on NPR talks about the
consent between patients with dementia. The interviewer asked the question
relating to the Iowa case, ‘what do we know about the woman and how she felt
about it.” A reporter named Bryan Gruley answers, ‘we don’t really know.’ He
goes on to say that through his research, he didn’t find anything that said
that reporters or law enforcement asked the man or woman what happened. He also
mentions that the night the nurses stopped the sex, the woman was kicking,
screaming, and biting the nurses. Many of the documents mention that when the
woman was with him she was happy and calmer. Unfortunately there really is no
clear cut answer.
Sexuality amongst anyone whether they
are young, old, heterosexual, homosexual, have dementia etc. is not black and
white. It is an extremely gray area, and I don’t think we will have a great
answer any time soon. But, this is something that is not as widely discussed as
it should be. There is not as much information on the topic, because many times
the elderly do not have the chance to talk about it because people assume that
the elderly do not engage in sexual activity. But whether it is sexual intimacy
in one’s home or in a nursing home we have got to raise awareness about the
issue, instead of making fun of them or saying that it’s ‘gross.’
Click on the link to check out a video that I thought went well with the topic. Sexuality in the Elderly
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.